A few weeks ago, on April 24, 2007, the world premiere of Antigone, the first opera by italian composer Ivan Fedele (born in 1953) opened the 70th Maggio Musicale Fiorentino.
Opera in sette quadri di Ivan Fedele
Libretto di Giuliano Corti
Una Guardia.....Bruno Lazzaretti
I didn't go, but I got the chance to listen to a recording made from the Rai Radio Tre live broadcast of the evening.
Thank God I didn't go.
This is not music to me. Let alone opera.
This is a succession of weird noises, with voices to cover up the failure (which they don't), with absolutely no musicality whatsoever.
Judging in comparison with Tan Dun's First Emperor, which received some well-deserved bad critics (which I agreed with), Antigone is far worse.
The score is, well, non-existing.
The melodic lines are, also, non-existing.
The use of the various instruments of the orchestra is, clearly, as bad as it gets.
And the global atmosphere coming from this so-called opera is that you're listening to the soundtrack of a very bad horror movie, hoping everybody dies fast, so this painful experience finally stops.
Of course, they don't.
And you end up either shooting yourself or shooting at the player, just to make this hell go away.
All about Jazz, Operaclick.
All photos Maggio Musicale Fiorentino.